Word Studies, Topical
Studies
Most of the time when we seek to
examine the Scriptures and apply them
to our lives in a practical sense, we are inclined to do "topical"
studies
or "word" studies. These have a useful place in comparison to
"Exegetical
Studies" (Exegesis),
but care must be exercised. This class will discuss the benefits and
fallacies
associated with topical and word studies, suggesting a methodology to
employ
when examining a particular topic from the Scriptures.
Word Studies
A "word study" is the idea of taking each occurrence of a particular
word (e.g. faith, love) in a single book or the entire Bible and
examining
those passages to learn more about the topic in question. However,
there
are several pitfalls and fallacies to be aware of when undertaking such
a study.
- Unless you have real expertise in original
languages, word studies are
not what they may appear to be on the surface!
- Words in the original language (OT- mostly
Hebrew, NT- Greek) are not
always
translated to the same English word.
- Example: The Greek term "parakaleo" is
variously translated in the NIV
as "comfort" (Mt 2:18, 5:4), "asking for help" (Mt 8:5), "begged" (Mt
8:31),
"pleaded" (Mt 8:34), "call on" (Mt 26:53), "exhorted" (Lk 3:18),
"invited"
(Ac 8:31), "urged" (Ac 9:38), "encouraged" (Ac 11:23), "appease" (Ac
16:39),
"request" (Ac 24:4).
- Different translations handle words differently.
- Example: In the same passages as above, the
NASB differs from the NIV
with
"entreating" (Mt 8:5, 8:31, 8:34, Ac 9:38), "appeal" (Mt 26:53, Ac
16:39),
"exhortations" (Lk 3:18, notice switch from verb to noun), "beg" (Ac
24:4).
- Some translations add words to assist in
translation and flow.
- Example: 1 Th 1:3 in NIV: " We continually
remember before our God and
Father your work produced by faith, your labor prompted by love, and
your
endurance inspired by hope in our Lord Jesus Christ."
- Example: 1 Th 1:3 in NASB: "constantly
bearing in mind your work of
faith
and labor of love and steadfastness of hope in our Lord Jesus Christ in
the presence of our God and Father."
- Not only the the NIV add the words
"produced," "prompted" and
"inspired,
it puts the entire passage into one sentence. The NASB translates 1:3
as
a phrase, a part of a much larger statement.
- What if you were doing a word study on
"inspiration" and came across
this
passage in the NIV? You might think the Bible teaches endurance is
"inspired
by" hope. But that's foreign to the original text!
- Technical terms: Certain words are used as
"technical terms" and are
not
as open to some of the other issues raised here.
- Example: The Greek "baptidzo" is always
translated "baptize."
- Caution: Ideas can be discussed though the
technical term normally used
to describe it may not be. Example- Jn 3:5, Tit 3:5 where baptism is
referred
to but not stated explicitly.
- Did you notice in the first sentence in the
paragraph above how I used
"word" in the first part of the sentence, and "topic" in the second
part,
as though they are equivalent concepts? They are not! This is the chief
pitfall in word studies, but it also points the way to a better way to
study out ideas and concepts.
Topical Studies
Topical studies are preferred over
word studies for the purpose of
learning about Christian teachings and ideas. There are four keys or
general
guidelines to employ when doing a topical study.
- Directness: Rarely will the Biblical
writer
directly answer your
question (usually because it wasn't relevant to his discussion). In
fact,
he is answering someone else's question. His answer to that question
can
help answer your question, but certain aspects of your question may
remain
unaddressed.
- Relevance: Make sure the topic you are
considering is addressed
in the passages you are examining.
- Understand which passages apply to the topic at
hand.
- Jewish Age: The Old Testament
- Christian Age: Acts through Revelation (Be
careful to distinguish the
apostolic
age from the post-apostolic age)
- What about the Gospels? Sometimes the gospels
address the Jewish age
(e.g.
Mt 5:23), sometimes the Christian age (Mt 18:20), and sometimes both
ages
(e.g. Mt 6:2-4). Consider the context!
- Explicit or Implicit? Differentiate
between
explicit teaching (what
do the Scriptures explicitly say?) and teaching by example (what do the
Scriptures say the early church believed and/or practiced?).
- What do the Scriptures teach, and how did the
early church put that
teaching
into practice?
- Normative or Informative? Differentiate
between normative and informative
passages. Consider if the example is meant as an example (normative) or
simply mentioning what someone did (informative).
- Example: Acts 2:38-41 appears to be normative
teaching on
conversion
in the early church, whereas Acts 10:9 appears to be informative
about what Peter happened to be doing (praying at noon on the roof).
Final Thoughts: Think
"Concepts"
The bottom line in studying out
concepts, doctrines and ideas from
the Bible is this: think "concepts" and "ideas." See the big picture in
the Scriptures, then examine relevant passages accordingly. Pay
attention
to what is said in those passages, but don't get so caught up in the
details
of the language that you lose sight of the context and the big picture.
Assignment
Word Study
Assignment.